Thread: Who will be dropped for the first test of the summer?
View Single Post
  #25 (permalink)  
Old 03-04-2007, 12:20 PM in reply to pie_chucker's post starting "More to the point how on earth did..."
cantplaycantalk cantplaycantalk is offline
(PAK) Passed Abdul Qadir's 1029 Test runs
  
Join Date: Mar 2004
My main national team: I support more than one national team
My other team/s: Durham, England, West Indies
Posts: 1,032
To be honest I wouldn't bring Vaughan back, England probably will, but I wouldn't.

The 4 bowlers option has some merit if Jones is fully fit but I think England will go for 5.
My guess and my prefered teams below side by side

Cook Cook
Strauss Strauss
Vaughan Bell
Peiterson Peiterson
Collingwood Collingwood
Flintoff Flintoff
Nixon Nixon
Jones Plunkett
Harmison Jones
Hoggard Hoggard
Panesar Panesar
For me I think unless Vaughan is willing to become an alrounder and do plenty of spin bowling in a 4 man attack he does not rate his place. If we can't have Read as effectively a non batting keeper how can we justify Vaughan as a non batting captain.
Reply With Quote