Cricinfo have produced a different verdict: 6 players are marked lower (massively lower in the case of Harmison and Collingwood) whilst Sidebottom and Broad finally get more credit,

Michael Vaughan - 6/10 - 5/10

Alastair Cook - 7/10 - 7/10

Ian Bell - 7/10 - 6/10

Kevin Pietersen - 4/10 - 4/10

Paul Collingwood - 7/10 - 4/10

Ravi Bopara - 3/10 - 3/10

Matt Prior - 5/10 - 5/10

Ryan Sidebottom - 6/10 - 7/10

Steve Harmison - 8/10 - 6/10

Matthew Hoggard - 7/10 6/10

Monty Panesar - 4/10 - 4/10

James Anderson - 4/10 - 3/10

Stuart Broad - 4/10 - 5/10

Cricinfo - Overestimated England slip further