View Single Post
  #22 (permalink)  
Old 26-12-2007, 10:40 AM in reply to acker's post starting "Your such astute judge of openers in..."
Rachael Rachael is offline
Administrator
WAT selector
Selector-World XI (1980 onwards)
(ENG-captain) Passed Mike Atherton's 7728 Test runs
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Norfolk
My main national team: None - I support cricket in general
Posts: 7,835
Quote:
Originally Posted by acker View Post
I was disgusted these two amatuers stumbled and bumbled their way to about 140 runs together [...] They are only shadows of the England opening batter's...whatsisname and whoishe
Well, they did better than the much vaunted pairing lower down the order:
Quote:
Originally Posted by cricinfo
Put a short midwicket in for Andrew Symonds, who was swishing wildly, and you had a wicket. Slip in a googly to Adam Gilchrist and you had a wild hoick - a shot that was as ugly as the word itself
That said... Jaques was exposed pretty badly in the opening overs: prodding nervously... then playing and missing: by the 3rd over cricinfo were saying "Zaheer has really got into Jaques's mind right now - the batsman prodded a nothing shot away from his body with little foot movement". He got off the mark with a leading edge and his composure in the 8th over was exemplary:
Quote:
7.5 Singh to Jaques, no run, wide outside off, kept a touch low but that didn't stop the batsman flashing away from it
Despite the conditions, Jaques was playing a cut shot in the 7th over and a pull (that didn't connect) in the 9th: madness. His discipline didn't improve in a hurry, either:
Quote:
16.2 Ganguly to Jaques, no run, wild seam movement away, the batsman tries to cut, but slices over it
Hayden was just plain lucky: first boundary off a thick edge... then a thick edge through the recently vacated third slip... then got away with a mistimed, lofted flick of a pull over midwicket that (sadly) reaches the rope even though it wasn't timed. Wasn't much better when Harbhajan started:
Quote:
17.1 Harbhajan Singh to Hayden, no run, a horrible, horrible... but comical shot... Hayden chasing a wide one and not letting it go, playing away from his body, and chopping down a bottom edge
At the end of the 16th over cricinfo noted "If you're just logging on now, the scoreline flatters Australia a touch; there have been plenty of play-and-misses, but latterly the pair are bringing things together"

Now there's no saying Vaughan and Cook would have been exemplary in their place... but I would at least expect greater discipline and more effort to play straight.
Reply With Quote