Thread: cricket changes
View Single Post
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 03-05-2004, 08:16 PM in reply to Scott-Wozniak's post starting "Well I'd like to see far more..."
Richard Jenkins's Avatar
Richard Jenkins Richard Jenkins is offline
WAT World Cup Predictor
(ZIM-captain) Passed David Houghton's 1464 Test runs
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Méron, France
My main national team: None - I support cricket in general
My other team/s: Cricket
Posts: 1,485
Send a message via MSN to Richard Jenkins Send a message via Yahoo to Richard Jenkins
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scott-Wozniak
Well I'd like to see far more technology used in umpiring decisions. I know this is an old chestnut with many people, and there are good arguments for and against this, and I'm fully aware of the main thrust of the 'detractors' arguments, but at the end of the day, in my mind, getting the right decisions made is the over-riding factor. Too many games these days can turn on on a 'poor decision' (Lara's 400 is an excellent example) and as the games get tighter and more competitive the need to ensure the correct decision is made becomes even more important.

I'd like to see the bowlers 'front foot' fault linked to a laser that 'beeps' when its over stepped, similar to that used for Tennis line calls.

I'd like to see more LBW decisions and 'nicked catches' being referred to the third umpire, who, with the use of television replays and technology such as 'hawkeye' can be much better informed about making a decision one way or the other. In my mind it is simply not acceptable in this modern age, that Umpires can get away with making poor decisions, when the technology is there to enable the correct ones to be made. Perhaps the third Umpire should be given the power to over-rule the standing Umpire in 'dubious' cases or the Captain of the fielding side or batsman given the power to challenge a decision he feels is wrong by having it referred to the third umpire, with the necessary precautions in place to ensure thar priviledge is not abused.

Scott
Yes,I agree. Test matches aren't 100mph breakneck affairs and it would help the umpire . looking for help is a sign af great sttrenth and the line decisions are a crowd pleaser. I like the beep front foot idea, hadn't thought of that.
__________________
I have a dream.... (Martin Luther King)