I am involved in a high stakes fantasy cricket comp at the moment. I have chosen Warne as my all rounder for both games and even after Flintoff's fine performance this test, Warne has provided more points. Thus, i consider Warne the superior all rounder. Also, if you look through his test record in stats guru, you will notice that this is only the second time in his test career when he has taken wickets and scored runs in the same test.
This match was an exception to his usual test performance - he rarely performs in with bat and ball in the same test which is why i would need far more convincing to rate him an allrounder of notable worth.

__________________