I'll continue the trend-bucking. I think Dhoni has some real talent and India should definitely stick with him. He has performed really well in ODI's as of yet and he could be a force to be reckoned with if the selectors stick with him.

I think in terms of aggression, there is a defnite link between him and Gilchrist and possibly Dhoni could get to that level with both bat and gloves one day.

However you could also make the point that with such a feard batting attack (ignorant of form in this point) what is the need for a wicket keeper who can bat really well? Why not have a great keeper that can hold a bat just about when you still have Pathan to come in.

__________________
Watch this for a perfect about.
James May