Playing Giles in the first test may have been smart, playing defensively and maybe draw the first test. Though all it achieved was a heavy defeat. Panesar should have played the second test and should definately play the 3rd in Perth, as we are 2-0 down in the series it is time to take it to the aussies. For all the people who say he isnt proven, the guy bowled Younis Khan in the pakistan tour. Panesar must play