who do you think the worst decision making umpire is?

i think its aleem dar if you were watching aus v sa he gave poor decisions example andrew symonds where it was going to hit the 5th stump if there was one!

please explain why you think theyre the worst?

Koertzen for me.Will be no surprise to anybody that he gets my vote but he just makes too many basic errors.

And to cover em up he says technology shouldn't be used. His ******** was spared in the Super Series by technology!!! Koertzen for me.

Koertzen as well for me, he makes some very dodgy calls. Although I have to say that we shouldn't just spend our time having a dig at all the umpires as they do usually do a very good job and I'm sure that if we tried to do umpiring we would make mistakes also.

__________________
Watch this for a perfect about.
James May

Yes Koertzen i would think- Aleem Dar is second worst tho-

__________________
Theres a light at the end of every tunnel...
Lets hope its not a train......

I feel this is an terrible Thread. Umpires have a terrible time as it is. I will not be voting nor contributing to this thread...