I have a few ideas regarding not just the World Cup but the entire ODI format, but I don't think anyone will listen. Here goes anyway:
- While I accept that some form of fielding restriction would be required in the ODIs to keep the game flowing, I do not like the idea of powerplays or any other form of alteration of the fielding setup during a game.
- IMO, a maxiumum of four outfielders should be allowed beyond the 35-yard circle throughout the 50 overs. The fielding captain would be free to use them in any position, including within the circle if he wished, as long as the total number beyond did not exceed 4.
- No other fielding restriction of any kind; certainly, no 'compulsory close catchers' etc.
- Wides should be more properly and strictly regulated. At the moment, bowlers suffer if the ball is more than a few inches outside the leg stump, while they get away with ridiculously wide deliveries on the off side. Umpires must be trained to use the 'line rule' more effectively.
- Day-Night matches should be banned totally from the 50-over game. Grounds with floodlighting facilities can use them for 20-20 games that start and end after dark.
For the Cricket World cup itself, I feel that some sort of balanced format is required, one that allows the 'minnow' countries to take part - after all they do add a bit of fun element to the competition - without making the tournament too long like this time around. IMO, having a straight knockout immediatly after the first round is too drastic because it will eliminate a big team for one bad day - remember, it may be
your team! Therefore, I believe the following format is best:
- A First Round of 16 teams in 4 groups (say A,B,C & D) of 4 teams each - exactly like it was in this World Cup. Two pints for a win, 1 for tie or no result and zero for a loss as before. The top 2 teams from each group progress to the second round, but do not carry over any points.
- A Second Round, where the 8 teams making it are reshuffled. The winners of Groups A & D together with the runners-up from B & C make up a Group 1 while the Runners-up from A&D and winners of B & C go to Group 2. The 4 teams in each of these 2 groups play 3 games each within their group exactly like the first round, with the same points system.
- The Semi-final, where the winner of Group 1 plays the runner-up of Group 2 and vice versa.
- The Final between the winners of the two semi-finals.
That way, every leading team gets a fair chance of going all the way without everyone having to play everyone else as it is now.
I believe in the provision of the extra day for rain affected matches, but I feel that
the Duckworth-Lewis rule should not be brought in at any time on the regular day. It should be enforced only at such time when it becomes obvious that the game cannot run its full course even on the second day - which is highly unlikely anyway.