| | |
| | |
| Welcome to the World-A-Team Cricket Forum. We promote friendly, good-natured, quality cricket discussion. |
| |||||||
| World A-Team Selections 2005 World A Team Selection Threads for 2005 |
| | LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
28-09-2005, 10:49 PM
in reply to The Phantom Ram's post starting "I'm only back from holiday today so I..." | ||||
| ||||
| Quote:
__________________ Administrator  |
|
28-09-2005, 10:56 PM
in reply to Rachael's post starting "We do need to exclude those youngsters..." | ||||
| ||||
| Quote:
__________________ Administrator |
| ||||
| Selectors XI - Key players in bold text. Code: Robs's XI Ernest's XI Andy Mellon's XI Kirsty Harris' XI Rachael's XI Batsmen Batsmen Batsmen Batsmen Batsmen Scott Newman ET Smith Alistair Cook A N Cook Cook Alistair Cook OA Shah Steffan Moore E C Joyce ? Collingwood MJ Chilton Owais Shah J Hidreth ? Owais Shah MJ Wood Ed Joyce O A Shah Joyce Ed Joyce EC Joyce Ravi Bopara S A Newman Shah Batting A/R Batting A/R Batting A/R Batting A/R Batting A/R Jamie Dalrymple PD Collingwood Paul Collingwood R Clarke Collingwood Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper James Foster MJ Prior Steve Adshead S J Adsheed Foster Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Graeme Swann Kabir Ali Dimitri Mascarenhas Kabir Ali ? Bowlers Bowlers Bowlers Bowlers Bowlers Mark Plunkett G P Swann Chris Tremlett M Davies Davies Kabir Ali C T Tremlett Monty Panesar G P Swann Tremlett Mark Davies LE Plunkett Mark Davies L E Plunkett Sidebottom
__________________ Administrator Last edited by admin : 29-09-2005 at 07:24 PM. |
| ||||
| Selectors XI - Key players in bold text. Code: DaveGillespie's XI Statto's XI Collyisamackem's XI Glamorgan Wanderer's XI Maranello's XI Batsmen Batsmen Batsmen Batsmen Batsmen SA Newman Newman AN Cook Newman Alistair Cook AN Cook Joyce OA Shah Cook Owais Shah EC Joyce Shah EC Joyce Shah Scott Newman OA Shah Cook PD Collingwood Joyce Ed Joyce PD Collingwood Sales AGR Loudon Collingwood Stephen Moore Batting A/R Batting A/R Batting A/R Batting A/R Batting A/R JWM Dalrymple Collingwood ID Blackwell Loudon Paul Collingwood Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper MJ Prior Sutton MJ Prior Adshead Matt Prior Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Bowling A/R Bowling A/R AGR Loudon Swann AD Mascarenhas Kabir Ali Kabir Ali Bowlers Bowlers Bowlers Bowlers Bowlers CT Tremlett Tremlett LE Plunkett Bresnan Chris Tremlett TT Bresnan Plunkett M Davies Tremlett Mark Davies LE Plunkett Davies CT Tremlett Davies Ryan Sidebottom
__________________ Administrator Last edited by admin : 29-09-2005 at 07:28 PM. |
| ||||
| I'm guessing that you haven't posted all the teams yet admin as mine isn't there. Are people able to change their sides - if they want to - now that Pansaner is confirmed as available for selection? From other threads I thought that Monty was a favourite amongst the posters.
__________________ Steven |
|
29-09-2005, 06:09 PM
in reply to The Phantom Ram's post starting "I'm guessing that you haven't posted..." | ||||
| ||||
| Hi Phantom, just your side and mine to post. Yes people can change their side to include Foster or Panesar if they want to. I'm still trying to decide on a couple of positions in my team so I'll post yours and mine when I'm done.
__________________ Administrator |
| ||||
| Don't think I'd change my side in light of the two new eligible candidates, but if the squads count for anything in the process I'd replace Batty with Panesar and Wallace with Foster in mine. |
| ||||
| Selectors XI - Key players in bold text. Code: The Phantom Ram's XI Mike's XI The Key Players:
(number of times picked in brackets)
Batsmen Batsmen Cook SA Newman Newman (1)
Wood (Somerset) AN Cook Cook (4)
Shah OA Shah Shah (3)
Joyce EC Joyce Joyce (5)
Stevens PD Collingwood Mascarenhas (1)
Davies (4)
Batting A/R Batting A/R Swann (1)
Tremlett (1)
Mascarenhas AGR Loudon Sidebottom (1)
Plunkett (1)
Wicketkeeper Wicketkeeper Kabir Ali (1)
Panesar (1)
Sutton MJ Prior
Bowling A/R Bowling A/R
Tremlett AD Mascarenhas
Bowlers Bowlers
Plunkett CT Tremlett
Davies M Davies
Panesar RJ Sidebottom
__________________ Administrator Last edited by admin : 29-09-2005 at 07:53 PM. |
| ||||
| Interesting that Collingwood, though selected by 10 of the 12 selectors, has not been chosen as a key player by a single one of them! Is he the ultimate utility selection? Good to have around, but not considered essential or indispensable by anyone? (Not even by Collyisamackem!) Some of the more popular choices amongst the 12 member selection panel, alongwith the number of key player votes they received, are: Code: Joyce 12 votes 5 key player nominations Shah 12 votes 3 key player nominations Cook 11 votes 4 key player nominations Collingwood 10 votes 0 key player nominations Davies 10 votes 4 key player nominations Tremlett 10 votes 1 key player nomination Kabir Ali 5 votes 1 key player nomination Newman 7 votes 1 key player nomination
__________________ A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes Mark Twain Last edited by Maranello : 30-09-2005 at 09:07 AM. |
| ||||
| Mike, at first glance I thought we had just enough key players there to have a team plus a 12th man (you have put up 12 names). However, no one has actually selected a keeper as a key player. Also, 7 of the 12 key players are bowlers or bowling all-rounders, while another (Mascarenhas) could probably be classified as either a bowling or a batting all-rounder. That leaves only 4 specialist batsmen nominated as Key Players.
__________________ A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes Mark Twain |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |
Linear Mode
